• Home
  • Work with me
    • Design Your Organization's Future
    • Additional Services >
      • Do you have the right program mix?
      • Impact mapping
      • Create New Offerings
    • Results >
      • Catching up on growth
      • Focusing on the right things
      • Learning from one another
      • Emerging from a crisis
      • Building shared leadership
  • Goodies
  • Podcast
  • Learn More
    • Carol Hamilton
    • Contact
Grace Social Sector Consulting, LLC
  • Home
  • Work with me
    • Design Your Organization's Future
    • Additional Services >
      • Do you have the right program mix?
      • Impact mapping
      • Create New Offerings
    • Results >
      • Catching up on growth
      • Focusing on the right things
      • Learning from one another
      • Emerging from a crisis
      • Building shared leadership
  • Goodies
  • Podcast
  • Learn More
    • Carol Hamilton
    • Contact

Mission: Impact podcast

Starting Too Small

3/27/2018

 
Picture

The Biggest Mistake Organizations Make When Doing Strategic Planning

​One of the most common mistakes is to start too small. Thinking you want to keep the process under control, senior management and the board often starts with themselves. These two groups have a pivotal role in strategic planning but its better if you shift their biggest involvement to later in the process. 

​The traditional process

​Traditionally, the entire process is held by a small leadership group. A few key players may be interviewed. A survey could be used to gather information from a wider set of stakeholders. The small leadership group has a retreat and comes up with a draft plan. They then ask for input from their stakeholders. This feels efficient and manageable. Yet the stakeholders who are asked for input after the major work has been done are likely to feel like this is a proforma request. Even if the document says “draft”, it usually feels like there is not a lot of room for change. As a result, the feedback you receive is often superficial.  You may even disengage your stakeholders rather than get the ‘buy-in’ you are seeking.

Flip the script

Instead flip the script and start big. Identify your key stakeholders and gather as many representatives together as possible. Bring them together for a 1-2 day summit. You may not believe it, but you can have over 100 people in the room and still have a productive conversation. With the support of dialogue technology, you can have even larger meetings – up to 1000 people participating – and have a productive conversation. Everyone does not have to be in the room as there are ways to engage people online as well.  Some tips include:
  • Split people into small groups of up to 8 people
  • Have each small group self-organize, choosing a facilitator, a timekeeper, a note taker and someone to do the report out
  • Use different methods to report out.
    • Try a gallery walk, during which each group posts their flip chart of discussion notes and everyone reads them individually and silently.
    • Have them create a headline or a tweet for their summary—and hold it up and read it.
    • Have them summarize the key take away from their discussion on a large stickie and post it in one place.
  • Use technology specially designed for large meetings (such as CoVision) to capture key takeaways and have a small team on site to synthesize the results in real time.

Inviting anarchy?

​Sounds like anarchy? With a good meeting design, it is highly energizing for both the stakeholders and the leadership. Bringing people into the process early helps them feel heard. They feel like they have a real chance to influence the end result. You are engaging them before the major goals of the plan are selected. 

Time to prioritize

​The small leadership group now makes meaning of the information generated in the larger session.  They shape it into a strategic plan, aiming for a few major organizational goals. By flipping the script and starting large, you have the benefit of many people’s thinking, you help them feel heard and your small leadership group still shapes the final product.

Thinking of engaging in a strategic planning process with your organization and want to learn more? Get in touch with me for a complementary coaching session.

What needs to be true for this to be a good idea?

2/27/2018

 
Picturephoto by Mindy Johnson
​This question helps you uncover the assumptions embedded in an idea.  Often assumptions for programs and services are hidden in three key areas: audience, problem and solution. For the idea to be a good one, you need to have found the right audience, correctly identified an important problem and designed a solution that is viable.

Let me give you an example. Using a design thinking approach to design new offerings for key segments of our organization’s audience, a team I led at my last association was able to design experiments that gave us feedback in each of these three key areas.

​Audience

In one instance, we had designed a program for one audience segment. After we tested the idea with the target audience and received positive feedback, we proceeded to run a pilot.  After successfully offering the program to one segment the association’s audience, we were able to replicate it for another audience.

​Problem

​Often this area is the most likely to trip you up. Have you identified a problem that is worth solving? Or a problem that is really critical for your target audience? Or is it just something that would be nice to solve? When hard choices are made about time, money and energy, this challenge gets put on the back burner.
 
To test our understanding of the problem, we wrote a problem statement or description of what we thought the problem was. For example: “association professionals often have a clear understanding of the views of their highly engaged volunteers, but are not sure that these reflect their average member.” Through our experiments, we were able to get feedback on how important each issue was.  With feedback we were able to eliminate a number of ideas that addressed problems that were not seen as critical.

​Solution

​When is the last time you got caught up in your idea and created something more elaborate than was really needed? In one case of one program we were testing with members, during the brainstorming stage, the design team had envisioned an executive leadership development program with an extensive online wrap around component. After testing and customer feedback, we learned that members were interested in the in-person aspect of the program. They doubted, however, that they would use the online components. Thus with a short testing period, we were able to eliminate a costly aspect of the program that would have be time consuming and resource intensive to create. It would have also necessitated increasing the program price, yet our research showed it did not provide sufficient value.
 
By testing early, getting feedback from customers we were able to learn and iterate, saving money and staff time by eliminating options that sounded promising at the white board but proved to have faulty assumptions. 

Want to talk about how this might apply to your organization? Request a free coaching session.

Translating Minimally Viable Product for the Nonprofit Sector

2/6/2018

 
Picture
​In my last post I described ‘Lean Start Up’ – a process that became popular in Silicon Valley and the business sector and now is gaining traction in the nonprofit sector. One of the key elements of lean start up is creating a ‘minimally viable product’ to use to test a new idea with customers. But how do you create a ‘minimally viable product’ for the types of programs and services that associations and nonprofits typically create? They are rarely concrete products that can easily be prototyped.
 
There are ways to test your program and service ideas with your target audiences. They range from storyboards to explainer videos to creating a concierge version of your service.  Answer the question – what is the simplest and least expensive way to test your idea? Ideally it enables you to test your idea by observing behavior.

​Storyboards

​Storyboards are essentially a ‘graphic novel’ or comic strip version of your idea. On one project I was facilitating, we used this technique to test our ideas with customers. We first had team members sketch out their idea – stick figures were just fine. This step helped team members push themselves to build out what sometimes was somewhat of a vague generic concept to delineating the concrete aspects of the program or service. We then had a professional illustrator clean up our crude sketches for testing with members. 

​Explainer Video

​Another possibility is to create a short video that explains and illustrates your idea. Dropbox used this method to test the viability of its service. They looked at how many people watched the video and more importantly how often people forwarded the video to test enthusiasm for the idea.

​Simple Web Pages

​Create a marketing page describing your idea. Perhaps it says it is ‘coming soon.’ Include a way to sign up and get more information. See how many people opt in.

​Concierge Service

Another alternative is to create a concierge version of your service. This is especially helpful when its full version would include automation. You build the basic marketing pages and for anyone who signs up staff process the item manually behind the scenes. Your goal is to see how many people enroll and the interest before you spend money on developing a complicated back end.
 
Learn more about storyboarding with this free resource.
 
Want to talk about how you might apply this to your situation? Get in touch for a free coaching session.

Storyboarding: Easy way to test program concept

9/5/2017

 

​Iteration Iteration

​You have probably heard that word a lot recently. Whether you are talking about adaptive management, design thinking or lean start up, each approach involves iteration and experimentation. Creating a prototype – something much simpler and less expensive than a pilot project – is easy to imagine when you are talking about a tangible product. But what about a program or service your nonprofit or association plans to deliver? How can you create a low cost prototype of that to get in front of your customers/members/audience?

​Blah, Blah, Blah

​Nonprofits and association staff often rely on describing their program – whether to their board or in a grant application – through words. It is then up to the listener/reader to imagine what they are talking about. And usually the focus was on convincing those with money to support this new venture.  If the pitch is successful, the program is then funded, usually as a pilot program is developed over a few years. 

4 flaws to this approach

This approach has multiple flaws that are easily addressed.
  1. The first is the audience. While it is important to get support of key stakeholders including your board and funders, they are unlikely to be using the program so their impressions of its validity and likelihood of success need to be taken with a grain of salt. Instead getting feedback from the people you have designed the program for this is much more useful and too often overlooked.
  2. The second is the advocacy stance. You think you have a great idea and you are pitching it. When you are in the mode, it is challenging to hear feedback about the program. If you are less attached to the idea and in a position of inquiry – you are ready to investigate the underlying assumptions embedded in the program’s design and listen to feedback. 
  3. Third is jumping immediately to the full development of a pilot program. Even with full funding, this is a high risk endeavor. It takes considerable time, human resources and organizational effort involved in fully developing a pilot.  Taking a less risky intermediate step of creating a prototype for the program and testing it with the target audience can save substantial resources.
  4. Fourth is relying solely on the spoken or written word.  Creating a visual representation of the program makes it much easier for people to literally see what you are talking about.  Storyboarding is a very accessible method for creating this visual.

​What is a storyboard?

​Movies, videos, TV shows are all story boarded before filming starts. The storyboard is a sequence of drawings that show how the shots will progress. For a program you have imagined, you draw the steps in the storyboard that a program participant would take as they complete your program. Think of it as the comic book version of the program you want to create. 

​But I can’t draw

Picture
​When I worked with the design teams a number of team members were reluctant when we got to this set because they said they couldn’t draw. I reminded them that this wasn’t the purpose – we were not looking for artistic ability. Just clear enough stick figures to show what would happen as part of the program. Here is an example of piece of one of our first draft storyboards. No awards to artistic merit here! We then worked with a professional illustrator to create clearer versions to put in front of our audience.

​Benefits of the storyboard

Picture
  • It is easy to produce. The first hand drawn versions took about 20-30 minutes for team members to create. Taking this step had the added benefit of nudging team members to push their concepts from just vague ideas to a program with concrete elements.
  • It is inexpensive. Even after working with an illustrator and printing the panels out on very large paper for our focus groups and interviews, we spent less than a couple 100 dollars.
  • It creates a visual story for your target audience member to react to.  By adding pictures to the descriptive elements, the proposed programs come to life in the minds of those we tested them with.
Download the e-book that walks through the approach and tells you how we tested our concepts.

Let’s talk. I work with associations and nonprofits to help them lower the risk out of launching new program and service development initiatives by coaching them on using human centered design innovation approaches and tools.



Why Being Customer Centered is Central to Your Innovation Strategy

8/14/2017

 
​Most organizations believe they keep their end user, audience, members or customers front of mind when they are creating new programs or service offerings.  Yet often this is based on preconceived notions about members, beliefs developed from a staff member’s time in the field, or based on interactions with a few of their volunteer leaders.  It is rarely based on an in depth exploration of the day-to-day work life of their members. Qualitative research digs into their experience and has the opportunity to uncover unmet needs. 

​ 
Find the Pain Points

​Organizations may have survey data and other feedback from members and participants.  This is useful for setting a baseline of knowledge but doesn’t often provide the insights into the challenges that your customers really need help with.  Using a human centered design approach for innovation provides tools to investigate what is really keeping your customers up at night and getting in the way of them achieving the success they seek.  Identifying these ‘pain points’ provides you will the opportunity to brainstorm how your organization might help solve the problem.

​Start with Lived Experience

​Start with your customer and learn about their lived experience today. You can do this by interviewing them, getting them to tell you about they interact with your organization - their customer journey -- and how they feel about it or providing them with a way to capture their experience each day for a specific period such as a video or web journal.  With this rich information in hand, a program design team then analyzes it for themes, looking specifically for the pain points that participants describe. These pain points are rarely uncovered from a direct question, such as, “what do you need help with?”  Too often people say they need something and then when it is offered, they do not end up buying it.  It is the challenges that emerge through inquiry that is less direct that are usually more fruitful for program or service development.

Uncover Unmet Needs

PictureLooking for insights
​For example, I was working on a project to design new offerings for a niche audience key to the association’s future. Other smaller organizations were providing services to this influential audience and the association did not want to lose their participation and membership. We started by interviewing 12 people that represented a cross section of this audience.  With the interview narratives complete, we gathered a group of staff to analyze the interviews for insights. We asked each person to note 30 items of interest on post it notes. Then we split the groups into teams and each team was to come to agreement on 4-6 themes that they saw in their insights. Engaging this wider group of staff had additional benefits of sharing the insights from the research with those beyond the core program development team. From the five sets of themes, our core team then synthesized the information, especially looking for statements of need. One need we identified was the need to connect with colleagues at their career level outside of the organization’s main conference. With this in mind, we created a number of options. After vetting and iteration through focus groups, the organization then launched a topic-focused retreat using the ‘unconference’ model. The program has since been successfully expanded to other senior audiences.

Tackle Problems Your Customer Actually Cares About

Taking the time at the front end of an innovation process to really dig into your member, your audience, your participants, your customers’ world sets you up for success.  Program or service prototypes still need to be tested with your end user before full development occurs.  But this important step helps ensure that you are looking for ways to solve problems your customer actually cares about.
 
Want to learn more? Let’s talk. I work with associations and nonprofits to help them put the customer at the center of their new program and service development initiatives. 

    carol Hamilton

    My passion is helping nonprofit organizations and associations have a greater mission impact.

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017

    Categories

    All
    Advocacy
    Associations
    Audience
    Awareness
    Board Development
    Book Review
    Branding
    Burn Out
    Business Model
    Change
    Change Leadership
    Communications
    Community
    Community Engagement
    Conflict
    Consultant
    Content
    Culture Fit
    Customer Centered
    Data Gathering
    Decision Making
    Decision-making
    DEI
    Delegation
    Design Thinking
    Digital Transformation
    Diversity
    Education
    Equality
    Equity
    Evaluation
    Executive
    Facilitation
    Funding
    Fundraising
    Grants
    Group Process
    Health
    Hiring
    Inclusion
    Influence
    Innovation
    Leadership
    Leadership Transition
    Lean Start Up
    Learning
    Lobbying
    Marketing
    Meetings
    Mentoring
    Messaging
    Mindfulness
    Mission Creep
    Money
    Nonprofit
    Nonprofit Life Cycles
    Nonprofits
    Online Meetings
    Online Organizing
    Operations
    Organization
    Organizational Culture
    Organizational Sustainability
    Organizations
    Pandemic
    Partnership
    Pause
    Poc
    Podcast
    Productivity
    Professional Development
    Reflection
    Reorganization
    Research
    Resolution
    Results
    Self Care
    Self-care
    Social Media
    Social Sector
    Somatics
    Storytelling
    Strategic Planning
    Strategy
    Strengths
    Succession
    Team
    Team Building
    Team-building
    Technology
    Transitions
    Trust Building
    Values
    Vicarious Trauma
    Virtual Environment
    Virtual Meetings
    Volunteers
    Wellness
    Workforce Development
    Workplace

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    Grace Social Sector Consulting, LLC, owns the copyright in and to all content in and transcripts of the Mission: Impact podcast, as well as the Mission: Impact blog with all rights reserved, including right of publicity.

Home    Work with me     Goodies     Podcast      About    Contact            


Telephone

301-857-9335

Email

info[at]gracesocialsector.com
Grace Social Sector Consulting, LLC, owns the copyright in and to all content in, including transcripts and audio of the Mission: Impact podcast and all content on this website, with all rights reserved, including right of publicity.
  • Home
  • Work with me
    • Design Your Organization's Future
    • Additional Services >
      • Do you have the right program mix?
      • Impact mapping
      • Create New Offerings
    • Results >
      • Catching up on growth
      • Focusing on the right things
      • Learning from one another
      • Emerging from a crisis
      • Building shared leadership
  • Goodies
  • Podcast
  • Learn More
    • Carol Hamilton
    • Contact